When Should You Rekey Locks for Your Fargo, ND Home?

Rekeying is the answer to one specific question every Fargo, ND homeowner eventually faces: how do I make sure old keys to my house stop working — without buying all new locks? A locksmith swaps the pins inside your existing cylinders to match a brand-new key, and every key that existed before that moment becomes scrap metal. Here are the five situations where that is exactly the right move.

What Rekeying Actually Does

Inside every lock cylinder is a row of spring-loaded pins cut to heights that match the grooves on your key. The right key lines the pins up at the shear line and the cylinder turns. Rekeying means disassembling that cylinder, pulling the old pins, and installing new ones cut to a different key. The lock body, the deadbolt, the handle — everything on the door stays. It takes minutes per lock, which is why it costs far less than replacement while delivering the same security result: old keys no longer work.

Freshly cut key made during a residential rekeying job

Five Moments That Call for a Rekey

1. You just bought or moved into a home

The previous owners, their relatives, their house sitter, their realtor’s lockbox, and every contractor who ever worked on the place may hold a working key. You cannot collect them all, so make them all useless. Rekeying should sit on the move-in checklist next to changing the utilities.

2. A key is lost or stolen

A lost key with nothing attached is a small risk; a lost key on a ring with your address tag or in a stolen purse with your ID is a direct one. If you still have another way in, a locksmith rekeys the affected locks and cuts fresh keys on the spot. If you are fully locked out, damage-free entry and a rekey happen in the same visit.

3. After a breakup or a roommate moves out

Even when the key gets handed back, you have no way to know whether copies were made along the way. Rekeying removes the question entirely — every duplicate dies with the original. It is a cleaner resolution than wondering, and far cheaper than new hardware on every door.

4. Between tenants

Landlords in Fargo’s rental market should rekey at every turnover as standard practice, not just after a bad exit. It protects the incoming tenant, limits your liability, and a locksmith can key multiple units to a system that still lets your master key work — one appointment per turnover, done.

5. After a break-in or attempted entry

Even if the lock looks undamaged, you do not know what the intruder learned, took, or copied. Rekey immediately, and have the locksmith inspect the hardware — a lock that was picked or forced may need repair or replacement rather than just new pins. Our residential locksmith services cover the full assessment.

What a Rekey Costs Depends On

The main factors are the number of locks, the hardware type (standard pin-tumbler locks rekey quickly; high-security cylinders take longer), and whether it is a scheduled visit or an emergency call. One efficiency worth asking for: having all your exterior locks keyed alike, so a single new key runs the whole house. Full details are on our rekeying services page.

A Cold-Weather Note for Fargo Homes

Fargo winters do not interfere with rekeying itself — new pins work the same at minus twenty as they do in July. What winter does attack is the keyway: moisture gets in, freezes, and blocks the key. After any rekey in fall or winter, a shot of graphite or silicone-based lock lubricant keeps the fresh cylinder turning smoothly through the cold months. We handle rekeys across Fargo year-round, mobile, with up-front pricing before the work starts.

Need a locksmith in Fargo? Bakken Locksmith serves Fargo and all of western North Dakota, 24/7. Call (701) 409-8700 and a locksmith picks up — not a call center.

Scroll to Top